8 strong Elder Scrolls opinions: With over 2,500 combined hours (and not all as stealth archers), we shout at each other about Skyrim, Morrowind, and Oblivion
Five PC Gamer editors with over 2,500 combined hours across The Elder Scrolls franchise have compiled their strongest opinions about the beloved RPG series. The editors have extensively played across Morrowind, Oblivion, and Skyrim, completing major storylines including defeating Dagoth Ur, closing the Oblivion gates, and destroying Alduin.
The roundtable discussion presents a collection of “hot takes” about the past and future directions of The Elder Scrolls, drawing from extensive hands-on experience with multiple entries in the series. Among the opinions discussed is the assertion that “The Elder Scrolls should be an RPG,” suggesting deeper conversation around the franchise’s design philosophy and mechanics.
Beyond their canonical achievements—slaying dragons, acquiring elder scrolls, and purchasing horse armor—the editors share candid perspectives on what works and what doesn’t across the series’ different eras. The piece is structured to encourage community participation, with voting buttons allowing audiences to indicate agreement or disagreement with each position, and space for readers to contribute their own perspectives.
The roundtable format reflects PC Gamer’s approach to fostering discussion around gaming franchises, particularly long-running series with passionate fanbases. By combining extensive practical experience with structured debate, the piece provides perspective that resonates with both casual players and dedicated Elder Scrolls enthusiasts who’ve invested hundreds of hours in these worlds.